BigMaclain,
Listen to what Andrea said. Maho Food Express is MUCH closer than Cafe Atlantico. Quick walk over to get baguettes, croisants etc. Also good lunch buffet as BigDenx mentioned.
Both Maho Food Express and Gourmet Marche in Simpson Bay will have everything you need, beer, juice, burgers, frozen pizza etc. There is also a 7Alive convenient store down the road from Gourmet Marche on A
Forum:
The Friendly St.Martin Island Forum