Both sides of the island have much to offer and that means dining also. The Dutch Side is not limited to hamburger joints as many will attest. Try Jimbo's, Valentino's, Le Bec Fin, Pineapple Pete's, SkipJacks, The Wharf, Temptations, Rare and Citrus to name just a few.
Some neat suggestions for alternate beaches to Orient (although I live here and I love Orient) would be Calmos Ca
Forum:
The Friendly St.Martin Island Forum