If the SXM - Anguilla - SXM ferry times work in your favour, or you charter a private water taxi (if available) you should have no problem going over to say, Shoal Beach, then somewhere nice for lunch, then head back to SXM. Sorry can't suggest any eateries as I haven't been recently, but have been before, and recall a beautiful thatched restaurant surrounded by shallow turquoise water
Forum:
The Friendly St.Martin Island Forum